TEXAS ETHICS COMMISSION

Ethics Advisory Opinions

EAO-590: Whether receiving a fee contingent on the sale of services to an independent school district is prohibited by Section 305.022 of the Government Code. (AOR-686).

SUMMARY

No. The Section 305.022 contingency fee prohibition does not apply to actions of an independent school district.

The Texas Ethics Commission is authorized by section 571.091 of the Government Code to issue advisory opinions in regard to the following statutes: (1) Chapter 572, Government Code; (2) Chapter 302, Government Code; (3) Chapter 303, Government Code; (4) Chapter 305, Government Code; (5) Chapter 2004, Government Code; (6) Title 15, Election Code; (7) Chapter 159, Local Government Code; (8) Chapter 36, Penal Code; (9) Chapter 39, Penal Code; (10) Section 2152.064, Government Code; and (11) Section 2155.003, Government Code.

Questions on particular submissions should be addressed to the Texas Ethics Commission, P.O. Box 12070, Capitol Station, Austin, Texas 78711-2070, (512) 463-5800.

Issued in Austin, Texas, on September 27, 2023.

TRD-202303774

James Tinley

General Counsel

Texas Ethics Commission

Filed: October 11, 2023


EAO-591: Whether a retired district court judge may use political contributions to pay for his and his spouse's headstones or monuments at the State Cemetery of Texas. (AOR-687).

SUMMARY

A retired district court judge may use political contributions to purchase a headstone or monument for himself and his spouse at the State Cemetery of Texas because the headstones or monuments are related to the requestor's activities as an officeholder and the headstone or monument will be the property of the state.

The Texas Ethics Commission is authorized by section 571.091 of the Government Code to issue advisory opinions in regard to the following statutes: (1) Chapter 572, Government Code; (2) Chapter 302, Government Code; (3) Chapter 303, Government Code; (4) Chapter 305, Government Code; (5) Chapter 2004, Government Code; (6) Title 15, Election Code; (7) Chapter 159, Local Government Code; (8) Chapter 36, Penal Code; (9) Chapter 39, Penal Code; (10) Section 2152.064, Government Code; and (11) Section 2155.003, Government Code.

Questions on particular submissions should be addressed to the Texas Ethics Commission, P.O. Box 12070, Capitol Station, Austin, Texas 78711-2070, (512) 463-5800.

Issued in Austin, Texas, on September 27, 2023.

TRD-202303775

James Tinley

General Counsel

Texas Ethics Commission

Filed: October 11, 2023


EAO-592: Whether Section 253.007 of the Election Code prohibits a former legislator from engaging in activity requiring lobby registration under various scenarios. (AOR-688).

SUMMARY

Section 253.007 applies to contributions to all candidates for and holders of non-federal Texas elective offices’ not just legislative or state executive branch offices. Once a triggering contribution is made, it cannot be cured by a refund or reimbursement. Section 253.007 also applies to a political contribution made to a political committee regardless of how the political committee ultimately disposes of the contribution.

The Texas Ethics Commission is authorized by section 571.091 of the Government Code to issue advisory opinions in regard to the following statutes: (1) Chapter 572, Government Code; (2) Chapter 302, Government Code; (3) Chapter 303, Government Code; (4) Chapter 305, Government Code; (5) Chapter 2004, Government Code; (6) Title 15, Election Code; (7) Chapter 159, Local Government Code; (8) Chapter 36, Penal Code; (9) Chapter 39, Penal Code; (10) Section 2152.064, Government Code; and (11) Section 2155.003, Government Code.

Questions on particular submissions should be addressed to the Texas Ethics Commission, P.O. Box 12070, Capitol Station, Austin, Texas 78711-2070, (512) 463-5800.

Issued in Austin, Texas, on September 27, 2023.

TRD-202303776

James Tinley

General Counsel

Texas Ethics Commission

Filed: October 11, 2023


EAO-593: Whether a written communication, created by a political subdivision and related to a measure, constitutes political advertising for purposes of the Election Code's prohibition against using public funds for political advertising. Tex. Elec. Code § 255.003(a). (AOR-689).

SUMMARY

The specific communication considered in this opinion is political advertising for purposes of Section 255.003 of the Election Code because it advocates for the passage of a measure.

The Texas Ethics Commission is authorized by section 571.091 of the Government Code to issue advisory opinions in regard to the following statutes: (1) Chapter 572, Government Code; (2) Chapter 302, Government Code; (3) Chapter 303, Government Code; (4) Chapter 305, Government Code; (5) Chapter 2004, Government Code; (6) Title 15, Election Code; (7) Chapter 159, Local Government Code; (8) Chapter 36, Penal Code; (9) Chapter 39, Penal Code; (10) Section 2152.064, Government Code; and (11) Section 2155.003, Government Code.

Questions on particular submissions should be addressed to the Texas Ethics Commission, P.O. Box 12070, Capitol Station, Austin, Texas 78711-2070, (512) 463-5800.

Issued in Austin, Texas, on September 27, 2023.

TRD-202303777

James Tinley

General Counsel

Texas Ethics Commission

Filed: October 11, 2023


EAO-594: Whether a written communication, created by a political subdivision and related to the political subdivision's special election for a sales tax ballot measure, constitutes political advertising for purposes of the Election Code's prohibition against using public funds for political advertising. Tex. Elec. Code § 255.003(a). (AOR-690).

SUMMARY

The specific communication considered in this opinion is not political advertising for purposes of Section 255.003 of the Election Code because it is entirely factual and does not include any advocacy.

The Texas Ethics Commission is authorized by section 571.091 of the Government Code to issue advisory opinions in regard to the following statutes: (1) Chapter 572, Government Code; (2) Chapter 302, Government Code; (3) Chapter 303, Government Code; (4) Chapter 305, Government Code; (5) Chapter 2004, Government Code; (6) Title 15, Election Code; (7) Chapter 159, Local Government Code; (8) Chapter 36, Penal Code; (9) Chapter 39, Penal Code; (10) Section 2152.064, Government Code; and (11) Section 2155.003, Government Code.

Questions on particular submissions should be addressed to the Texas Ethics Commission, P.O. Box 12070, Capitol Station, Austin, Texas 78711-2070, (512) 463-5800.

Issued in Austin, Texas, on September 27, 2023.

TRD-202303779

James Tinley

General Counsel

Texas Ethics Commission

Filed: October 11, 2023


EAO-595: Whether the Section 572.069 revolving door prohibition prevents a state university employee, who operates a business outside of his university employment, from bidding on behalf of his business on a procurement issued by the university. (AOR-691).

SUMMARY

Section 572.069 of the Government Code applies only to a "former state officer or employee of a state agency." The requestor is a current employee of the university and therefore is not subject to 572.069. However, the requestor should take care not to violate the standards of conduct for state employees listed in Section 572.051 of the Government Code or Chapter 39 of the Penal Code.

The Texas Ethics Commission is authorized by section 571.091 of the Government Code to issue advisory opinions in regard to the following statutes: (1) Chapter 572, Government Code; (2) Chapter 302, Government Code; (3) Chapter 303, Government Code; (4) Chapter 305, Government Code; (5) Chapter 2004, Government Code; (6) Title 15, Election Code; (7) Chapter 159, Local Government Code; (8) Chapter 36, Penal Code; (9) Chapter 39, Penal Code; (10) Section 2152.064, Government Code; and (11) Section 2155.003, Government Code.

Questions on particular submissions should be addressed to the Texas Ethics Commission, P.O. Box 12070, Capitol Station, Austin, Texas 78711-2070, (512) 463-5800.

Issued in Austin, Texas, on September 27, 2023.

TRD-202303780

James Tinley

General Counsel

Texas Ethics Commission

Filed: October 11, 2023